Miss Universe 2025: Fátima Bosch’s win sparks major controversy

New Delhi, November 21: By the time Fátima Bosch Fernández stepped off the stage in Nonthaburi, the lights were still blinding, the crowd still roaring, but the air in the room felt strangely uneven. People clapped, yes, but they also watched each other, almost as if trying to gauge whether they were witnessing a celebration or the tail end of a week that had spun out of control. The Miss Universe 2025 crown went to Bosch, but the story trailing behind her looked nothing like a clean win.

A Night That Didn’t Land Cleanly

The final show at Impact Challenger Hall had the usual sparkle. Cameras sweeping across the audience. Fans waving flags. Bosch is moving through the rounds with steady confidence. AP News confirmed her win, a milestone for Mexico, which now counts her as its fourth Miss Universe titleholder.

But even as she posed with the crown, it felt as if everyone in the building knew the coronation was only part of the story. Earlier that week, at a sash ceremony that was supposed to be little more than a photo op, the tone shifted sharply. Business Insider reported that Thai pageant director Nawat Itsaragrisil reprimanded Bosch publicly for missing a promotional shoot. It wasn’t a soft word in a quiet corner. It was loud. It was sharp. Contestants saw it, and some walked out.

Walkouts don’t happen in pageants. Not like that. Not spontaneously. The Miss Universe Organization later described the treatment Bosch received as serious abuse, which, frankly, is the sort of language that suggests they knew the damage couldn’t be brushed aside.

Instead of defusing things, the statement only pulled more eyes toward her. Online chatter swelled. According to the Hindustan Times, critics insisted Bosch was being pushed into a sympathy narrative and that her win, when it eventually came, looked staged through the lens of “repairing” the organisation’s image.

The Judge Who Quietly Walked Away And Left A Bomb Behind

Then came the resignation. Omar Harfouch, a judge, quit before the final. GMA Network reported that he claimed an unauthorised group had been shaping the finalist list. His words hit like a spark on dry grass.

View this post on Instagram
A post shared by Miss Universe (@missuniverse)

The Miss Universe Organization denied everything, but at that point the details mattered less than the impression. A judge leaving on the eve of the finale felt like confirmation for viewers who were already suspicious. And once trust wavers, it wavers fast.

To make matters worse, the night itself wasn’t exactly seamless. The Guardian noted that one contestant from Jamaica fell hard onstage and needed medical attention. Small incidents in large productions happen, but this one, stacked on a week full of tension, made the entire event feel shaky.

Bosch’s Personal Story Caught In A Crossfire

Bosch’s background her dyslexia and ADHD, diagnosed at six has long been part of how she introduces herself. The Indian Express highlighted how she often talks about the empathy those challenges instilled. Normally, such stories sit quietly in the biography section of a Miss Universe winner’s profile.

This year, though, supporters clung to her story like a lifeline, pointing to it as proof she’d weathered hardship long before Thailand. Critics, on the other hand, said it felt too conveniently emphasised, too ready to slot into a “resilient heroine” arc in the middle of a crisis the organisation was trying to survive.

Even her final response which Mint reported as one of the night’s strongest became another point of contention. Instead of being celebrated, it was dissected, doubted, and pulled into a wider argument that had little to do with her actual performance.

Thailand’s Pageant Scene Takes A Hit

Thailand has cultivated a reputation for hosting large-scale pageants with near-flawless precision. That reputation wobbled this year. One detail, in particular, set fans off. Business Insider pointed out that even after the organisation reportedly restricted Nawat for his behaviour toward Bosch, he continued attending major events.

It sent a mixed message. If restrictions aren’t enforced, what does that say about who holds authority behind the scenes? Thailand’s pageant fans took that question seriously. They know the industry intimately, and this year they’ve been unusually vocal about their disappointment.

The Bigger Questions Pageants Can’t Dodge Anymore

Miss Universe isn’t just entertainment. It’s branding, national representation, diplomacy, economics, and global visibility wrapped up in sequins. And everyone involved knows that.

That’s why this year felt different. The Guardian pointed out that the controversies didn’t just dent the pageant’s reputation. They exposed the kinds of questions that have lingered for years:
Who actually makes the big decisions?
How transparent is the scoring?
And how much influence do national directors have over what viewers think is objective ranking?

These aren’t small concerns. They’re structural. And they don’t vanish just because the crown has been awarded.

Bosch’s Road Crowded, Complicated, And Already Heavy

Bosch should be stepping into her year as Miss Universe with a clean runway ahead of her. Instead, she’s walking into interviews where she’ll be asked to comment on fairness, bias, and backstage behaviour things no contestant is trained to handle but is suddenly expected to answer.

View this post on Instagram
A post shared by Fatima Bosch (@fatimaboschfdz)

Her supporters will defend her. Her critics won’t budge. And the weight of that tension will shadow her appearances for months. That’s not her doing, but it becomes her reality.

And Miss Universe? It Has Work To Do

If the organisation wants to recover its footing, it will need more than polished statements. It will have to show what went wrong, how decisions were made, and why allegations from a resigning judge were dismissed so quickly. Without that transparency, the doubt around this year’s results will keep echoing every time Bosch steps onto a stage.

For now, the crown sits securely on her head, but the pageant around her looks less steady than it has in years. Fixing that won’t be quick, and it won’t be clean.

Stay ahead with Hindustan Herald — bringing you trusted news, sharp analysis, and stories that matter across Politics, Business, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Lifestyle, and more.
Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram, X (Twitter), LinkedIn, YouTube, and join our Telegram community @hindustanherald for real-time updates.