By Ayesha Khan 
Mumbai, November 27: The final season of Stranger Things arrived today with the kind of global noise Netflix loves, but the early reactions are far less uniform than the company might have hoped. Volume 1 lands with plenty of spectacle, yes, but also with a sense that the show is wrestling with its own legacy. You can feel the weight of nine long years in almost every frame.
Across the board, critics seem torn. Many still enjoy the ride, but almost everyone is pointing out the same cracks that have been widening since Season 4. It is not that the new episodes are bad. They are just no longer surprising.
And that is the part stinging longtime fans a little.
Strong Craft, Familiar Storytelling
The Hindustan Times review has become the early shorthand for this debate, calling the season “good but no longer great.” It is an odd thing to say about a series that still pours money into every explosion and monster screech, but it makes sense once you sit with the new episodes. They hit their marks, they raise the stakes, but they rarely feel new.
The nostalgia that once defined the show now feels like a routine it cannot stop performing. Big musical cues, tearful reunions, last-second rescues. All of them polished, all of them watchable, yet you can almost predict the rhythm before it happens.
The SlashFilm take is harsher on this front. It suggests the show is pushing so hard towards the finale that the pacing starts to feel squeezed. The feature-length episode format, once a bold experiment, now leaves entire scenes feeling like they wandered in from a different show just to keep up with the ensemble. There are emotional beats that should land harder but get swept up in the need to jump to the next plot thread.
The Cast Has Grown Up, Whether The Story Likes It Or Not
No single criticism is as persistent as the age question. The original cast was barely into their teens when the show began. Now they are adults with faces that no longer match the teenage anxieties the scripts cling to.
According to Vulture, this is the show’s biggest hurdle. The story refuses to let these characters age in real time, and the gap is too wide to ignore now. The camera can soften it only so much. The problem is not the acting; most of them bring more depth now than ever. But every time the script pushes them into high-school dilemmas, something feels off.
Still, the maturity of the cast gives a few arcs an unexpected edge. Some of the heavier emotional moments work because the actors have grown up. When scenes slow down and let them sit with loss or fear, the performances cut through the noise of the larger plot. The show just does not make enough room for those moments.
Dustin Ends Up Carrying More Heart Than Expected
One performance keeps coming up in early coverage: Gaten Matarazzo as Dustin Henderson. AwardsWatch calls his work this season “new depth and heart,” and it is not hard to see why. His arc carries a rawness the rest of the season sometimes struggles to reach. It feels lived-in, not performed, and gives Volume 1 a bit of soul in places where the storytelling thins out.
Younger characters such as Holly Wheeler also inject some freshness. If anything, a few critics argue the show might have benefited from leaning more into these newer dynamics rather than trying to keep every original character on equal footing.
The Horror And Visual Scale Still Impress
One thing even the more negative reviews agree on is the craft. The show still knows how to stage fear. It still knows how to paint the Upside Down as a place you’d rather not think about after dark.
The creature design, the lighting, the practical sets, the sound — all of it feels ambitious, even a little wild in spots. Some critics point out sequences that stand among the best in the series, proof that the Duffers have not lost their sense of how to build dread.
The trouble is that the bigger these scenes get, the more compressed everything else feels. Emotional beats that should linger sometimes flicker by, swallowed by the push toward the finale.
Fans Hold Their Breath For The Last Two Drops
Fan reactions, especially those gathered by The Times of India, are more forgiving. Many viewers seem relieved just to be back in Hawkins after the long wait. Social media is filled with people calling it “absolute cinema,” which may be a touch generous but speaks to how invested audiences remain.
But even in fan circles there is unease. Volume 1 feels like a setup. A necessary one, maybe even a sturdy one, but clearly not the full picture. And with Volume 2 due on December 25 and the final episode closing out the year on December 31, viewers are already treating these seven chapters as a warm-up rather than the main event.
A Season Caught Between What It Was And What It Has To Be
What makes the early reception interesting is how personal it feels. People grew up with this show. They were kids when the characters were kids. They are older now. And so is the cast. And so is the series. That shared timeline is now showing its seams.
Volume 1 is messy in places, impressive in others, and occasionally very moving. It does not quite recapture the electricity of the early years, but it also does not collapse under its ambitions the way some feared it might.
For now, it looks like a series stepping carefully toward its ending, hoping the final stretch delivers the kind of emotional payoff that lingers long after the dust in Hawkins settles.
Stay ahead with Hindustan Herald — bringing you trusted news, sharp analysis, and stories that matter across Politics, Business, Technology, Sports, Entertainment, Lifestyle, and more.
Connect with us on Facebook, Instagram, X (Twitter), LinkedIn, YouTube, and join our Telegram community @hindustanherald for real-time updates.
Covers films, television, streaming, and celebrity culture with a focus on storytelling trends.
- Ayesha Khanhttps://hindustanherald.in/author/ayesha/
- Ayesha Khanhttps://hindustanherald.in/author/ayesha/
- Ayesha Khanhttps://hindustanherald.in/author/ayesha/
- Ayesha Khanhttps://hindustanherald.in/author/ayesha/
